May 27, 2008

Micro Finance: A fledgling hope

I have heard since my childhood that India is a country of poor people and probably my parents might also had heard the same in their childhood some 3-4 decades back. It is more than six decades since we got our independence and at that time the country was visibly in a tattered state. In these decades we have seen many floods, cyclones and droughts along with green revolution, white revolution and IT revolution. We have seen population going from 24 to 110 crores. We have seen industries growing and now we have four business tycoons in the global top 10 rich list, still there are millions in the country who are considered as below poverty line even as per the developing world's standards with less than $1 per day income. This is quite ironical.

There are numerous reasons of this persisting problem which include India’s bloody history, foreign rule for centuries, cultural traits, illiteracy and corruption. Though the governments after governments have launched hundreds of schemes to alleviate poverty, still, the poor do not have water to irrigate their fields, money to send their children to school and for health and sanitation. Government machinery has almost completely failed to deliver. Traditional banking system has refrained itself from this segment to provide any financial support, throwing them into the whirlpool of high interest rate debts but in the recent years they have found a new hope in Micro Finance.

My last week’s visit to Ujjivan, one of the India’s fastest growing Micro Finance companies for urban poor, was as eye opener for me as it was enlightening. I saw people from very promising backgrounds working there in that non flashy and modest environment. Even some foreigners were there. Mr. Samit Ghosh, the founder of Ujjivan took us down his memory lane and explained what made him think of micro finance and the modal that they have selected. Ujjivan gives loans to urban poor women in groups and these loans are mainly for the purposes such as to repay old loans which were taken on a very high rate, for business purposes, education, marriages etc.

As per the data presented to us and as per many other studies also, there are some 100 million people in India who can get benefited from such services. This segment of society is underserved because of inherent risk involved in terms of bad debts and frauds. These micro finance institutions have brought a new hope for the poor in the country. We can see a whole new breed of micro entrepreneurs because of this.

Even after such huge appeal, micro finance has to reach to its full potential. There are many challenges in the path. These challenges are on various fronts. The first thing is that traditionally this activity was undertaken by NGOs in the non-profit form. The drawback of this format was that it was not scalable enough due to the lack of capital. Then some daring entrepreneurs like Samit Ghosh and Vikram Akula of SKS Microfinance started profit oriented institutions. With this profit making approach they have been able to attract capital investments from investors but there is a long way to go.

The second main problem is cost effectiveness. Micro finance operations are field operations and data collection is manual. This data has to be processed in the back office and has to be fed in the database. This process not only requires efforts in terms of time but also cost a significant amount to these companies. With increasing competition this problem has become even more severe. To address this problem many institutions have turned towards technology. Many pilots are being done to automate the process but a significant impact is yet to be seen. There are many reasons behind the limited success of such projects. The cost of such equipments, lack of know-how among the field staff who are supposed to use these equipments, continuing support by the technology providers and frauds are some of the main reasons.

It is my belief that there are a lot of things that can be done to solve the second problem in terms of technology. Less fancy and cheaper equipments can be made which will run software built on open source base, providing features like thumb recognition, face recognition and data entry in electronic form. This data then can be transferred over the telecom network or internet to the central location. Once we have the data in electronic form it can be processed in any way we want at a much faster pace, reducing the time and cost of operations. However, building these equipments is not the complete solution till the people who are supposed to use these are not able to do so. For that the training will have to be provided. It has been told to us that this is very tedious job looking at the capabilities of field staff but somewhere we will have to start.

Apart from these problems they face some of the logistic problems such as lack of proper or foolproof process. Most of these institutions being new in the game do not have know how of key important things like financial modeling, risk analysis, cash flow management, and right model to bank on but with experience they are overcoming these problems gradually. The one thing that has to be taken care of immediately is the talent crunch in the sector. This sector does not provide cushy and flashy jobs like other main stream banks and because of that not many talented people are wiling to work there. Though I have seen some people full of passion and from a very strong background putting their efforts but the things have to be speed up.

One thing that I am hopeful about is once a couple of cycles will get over of these micro loans to the poor people, in the future cycles they will deploy these loans to much productive purposes like financing their small business ventures. We will see the real impact of this concept only when it will start empowering the poor masses at a very large scale. In the parts of the country where this concept has gained the ground, we can already see changes. I am sure looking at these examples other parts of the country will also follow, though in pockets. Concluding this writing, I would like to say that Micro-Finance has a lot of potential to achieve a greater good for the poor masses, it is a fledgling hope which has to be nursed carefully.

Reliance Communications buys Vanco: A strategic fit

“Karlo duniya mutthi me”

This was the slogan of Reliance communications (erstwhile Reliance Infocomm) for its first ever ad campaign some 5-6 years back. This slogan was in line with the great visionary and founder of Reliance group Late Dhirubhai Ambani’s dream of making mobile communication cheaper than a post card for Indians. The war which Reliance Infocomm started has resulted in the lowest tariffs in the world for Indian mobile phone users. Reliance Communications now an arm of ADAG, which is controlled by the younger Ambani, is the second largest mobile phone operator in the country. In spite of some initial setbacks it has established itself strongly in the market.

The saga of mobile phone business is apparent to us and everyone knows about it but the strategy on which the company is working is very interesting to look at. Now Reliance communications is not just a mobile phone service provider, it is a lot more. With a slew of acquisitions over the past 4-5 years it has developed a business proposition which makes it as not only the provider to normal users but one of the major players in the enterprise level communication services.

On the onset it created nationwide optical fiber network of 10s of thousand kilometers to carry its data at high rate at a lesser cost. This network was built keeping in mind the future data requirement of the country as at that time internet penetration was very minimal. This has proved very effective to Reliance. Apart from using this network for its own purpose the additional bandwidth is leased out to the other parties. This high bandwidth network allows Reliance to venture into much more value added and content rich services like internet TV with a promising quality of service.

To take this OFC network global, Reliance acquired a French company Flag Telecom some four years back. Flag telecom was one of the largest OFC network operators in the world at that time with its cables connecting all the continents and all the main countries in the world. It allowed Reliance to enjoy least possible cost for its data traffic of international calls and internet. Several other international companies take bandwidth on lease from Flag Telecom. With its financial muscle Reliance revived the sick company and its network has increased significantly since then.

Last year it acquired Yipes in the US which operates in Ethernet management and application delivery business. Riding on Flag’s global network Yipes services are being deployed globally. Yipes, which had some 2000 enterprise level clients at that time, helped Reliance to move up the value chain and closer to its enterprise level customers. This strengthened Reliance’s presence in the data communication business with a futuristic view.

Now yesterday Reliance Communications has acquired UK based Vanco, a MVNO provider who operates on the global scale. MVNO(Mobile virtual network operator) is a virtual network operator who does not have its own physical network infrastructure. It buys bulk network usage from the existing providers and then sells it to the enterprise level clients who want to deploy their services over the mobile phone networks. These enterprise customers can be anyone ranging from banks to airlines to retail chains. Vanco, which is a financially troubled company has operations in 200 countries and offers some 800 products to its customers. It has contracted revenues of more than $650 for next 3-5 years. Now with Reliance communications in the picture with its international OFC network, Vanco can route its traffic through this network rather than relying on other networks and paying a large portion of its revenues to the network bandwidth providers. On one hand this will reduce the operating cost of Vanco significantly and on the other hand unutilized bandwidth of Flag will generate extra revenue. This will bring several new customers to Reliance’s kitty which will help it to consolidate its position in the market. This is a win-win deal for all the parties.

The model which has been developed for Reliance Communications operations reminds us the model Reliance developed for its petroleum business and the same model is being used in other key businesses of Reliance. They want to do everything own their own. They cover the entire value chain squeezing even the last possible penny. Reliance Communications these back to back strategically fit acquisitions really makes it a formidable player in the communication industry with a wide spectrum of services.

May 15, 2008

Mobile Banking: It's not a buzz

Everyone knows about the growth rate of wireless communication especially in countries like India and China. Millions and Millions of users are being added each month. All the businesses around mobile telephony are witnessing high growth rate be it mobile phone manufacturers, operators, vendors or be it network infrastructure providers. This business has generated multi-billion dollar organizations with multi-billion dollar owners.

Amidst of all this buzz mobile companies around the world are getting more and more worried of stagnation in growth rate in developed nations with many countries are already approaching towards 100% mobile penetration. There are hardly any differentiators available to these companies in terms of products, services and pricing. Though they are banking on high growth rates in emerging markets and third world economies, still, the present scenario is pushing them to innovate something that can take them to the next growth trajectory.

One concept that is gaining ground for past few years is Mobile Banking. Though at the time of telecom boom in 90's, it was predicted that Mobile banking would be the next killer thing in technology world and would take the by surprise, it didn't happen that way. Even though mobile telephony has seen high growth rate, mobile banking has remain in its infancy till date or there are very few example where it has gained the significant ground. Does this show that Mobile banking or m-banking as many call it, will remain a distant dream or will not be a killer thing? According to me the answer is YES and NO.

First let us look at more important one, 'NO'. All around the world we have many practical examples of m-Banking services going live, though in pockets. In numerous studies and surveys by some of the world largest market and technology research organizations it is predicted that a major chunk of the mobile phone users is ready to start using these services, provided meaningful or high value services are provided by the operators. Further, even larger chunk would like to explore the possibility but is apprehensive because of inherent security and privacy issues. Many people are even not aware that such services are available or possible on mobile phones. This is lack of marketing and publicity, which can be handled. So if the users are open to explore the possibility, then what is the hindrance?

According to me the problems are both technological and non-technological. Both of these categories require different approach to be solved and in fact great deal of efforts are going to resolve them at various levels. The first and foremost problem is security and is the main reason of apprehension by the users and the banks who are still uncertain to some extant whether to launch these services or not. Security related issues are already addressed by most of the technology providers of such services and with the help of encryption it is already being considered as equivalent to the internet banking, so the need is to educate the stakeholders.

Second most important issue is continuously evolving technology and lack of standards. Mobile banking technology is still evolving and various players are banking on different technologies through small scale projects. Due to this uncertainty many banks and institutions are still unsure, to which technology they should bank on. But this situation is expected to get better keeping in mind that some technologies have already started gaining upper hand over the others.

Next is enabling environment, this can consist of various factors and can help in development and large scale acceptance of such services. One of the main points in this area is government norms and specifications by various other regulatory bodies. Most of the countries don’t have any norms in place to control banking through mobile phones which in real sense is not supposed to involve banks. Sensing the need of such norms, central banks across the world are engaged in brain storming and some of them have already come up with initial set of guidelines. Central bank of Philippines has become a case study for such efforts. Reserve Bank of India is also scheduled to release such guidelines in a month’s time. This clearly shows that though the progress in this has been slow but the things are catching up now.

The last point that I would like to give emphasis on is infrastructure. The prime requirements for the success of mobile banking in terms of infrastructure is high level of mobile penetration, relatively high end handsets, well established banking system and wide network coverage. I believe any of these parameters is not a concern in the developed world and in developing world also things have improved at a frantic pace in past few years. This provides to the interested companies, economy of scale and ensures that their services will be cost effective. Even in underdeveloped countries such as African countries, wireless services are catching up at a fast pace.

When all the things are moving in the right direction, may be at a relatively slower pace, the need of time is to develop sustainable business model around such services. Looking at the varied level of economic development and market requirements, it is quite apparent that there is no one-shot solution for this. Service providers will have to study the markets individually and depending upon the local requirements they will have to innovate their services.

Now comes ‘YES’. Though most of the players in banking and financial industry along with the players in telecom industry feel that, to reach out to the masses and provide Anytime Anywhere banking, they will have to go for mobile banking, still their level of investment is at very minimal level. Only a fraction of subscriber base is inclined towards such services due to the reason cited above. In various parts of the world companies have tried multiple models, but the success of any particular model have been very limited. One other key issue that is being raised is seamlessness. Once the user opts for a particular service she should not be bounded to stick to that. Though some efforts have already started to address this issue by bringing multiple accounts in the same card, still there is a long way to go.

So looking at all these aspects I believe that though the Mobile Banking is on the threshold to take a big leap, still many stakeholders will have to work in sync to make it work. This will not only be helpful for the large companies who are striving for growth but also to the people who are striving to get the access to the banking services and are located at the remote locations.

May 12, 2008

Reliance's BIG Entertainment: Why Reliance is so reliable?

Another BIG news from the Reliance stable, this time from Anil Ambani camp. Group's entertainment arm is going to announce big ticket projects and contracts at Cannes, next week. These announcements which are expected to run into several hundred million dollars involving bigwigs like Will Smith, Tom Cruise and Anglina Jolie will bring the company on the center stage of international entertainment world. Reliance Big Entertainment as it is named, having George Soros as its one of the main investors is looking at another 10% stake dilution to big names like KKR and Carl Icahn.

Though such big announcements from Reliance do not astonish the business world anymore as everyone has become used to of it yet in this case the glamour associated with the matter in hand and a whole new line of business in case of Reliance is generating a lot of interest. Reliance's move in this territory, full of unpredictability and big bets is going to be a next thing to watch. Earlier also, ADAG acquired some 200 screens in 28 cities in North America targeting mainly the audience from Asian countries, but this move will bring them in the main stream Hollywood. Back home in India also, Big Entertainment is already creating ripples in the industry. With Adlabs, it is already one of the major players in the multiplex and post production business and is charting out big plans in other segments in the entertainment world. It has signed various contracts with major directors, actors and studios for movie production in various languages and investing in areas such as animation and gaming. After acquiring stake in Nitin Desai Studio it is aiming to make it one of the biggest studios in the world, on the lines of Universal and others.

After so much of skepticism and criticism ADAG's plans seem to be taking shape now. George Soros who acquired 3% stake in the Big Entertainment for $100m valued it at $3b and now the company is eying at the valuation of $5b.

With most of its plans still in the pipeline what is the thing that is making the company already a BIG hit? This is surely the legacy of Reliance group as a whole for designing new games or changing the rules of the game altogether. We have giants like Warner Brothers, 21st Century, Sony Pictures and many others in the world of entertainment who are established for decades and know the game better than anybody else in the world. Still, when Anil Ambani dreams of becoming the No.1 in the entertainment, everyone claps to support him. With the muscle power and the power to influence it has, it looks very realistic that Reliance will make it through this time too.

Be it Patalganga Plant, Jamnagar Refinery, Textile, Reliance Communications, Reliance Retail, Infrastructure, Power, Real Estate and many other businesses, the group has proven its mettle in every field. With many other business such as shipping, mining, oil exploration, fertilizer, cement, consumer items in pipeline and that too on national and international scale in each of the cases, there is no doubt that this BIG entertainment will also take off and will open yet another frontier of India's mounting might in the international corporate world.