In the entire process of starting my MBA, the most painful part was getting Education Loan from India and this exposed me to some complex and some unprofessional side of the loan process. I wish to share my experience on some key points in this post so that others going on this path can avoid some of the trouble.
Start the process as early as possible
All the MBA aspirants apply to multiple colleges and some people get multiple admits as well. However due to various reasons such as multiple rounds of applications, wait list or others the admits come at different times from different institutes. So as soon as you get the first admit and you are sure that you will join the program if you don't get any other, apply for the loan but first check with you respective bank if you can later get it converted for some other program at no or very little extra cost. This will save you a great deal of time.
Prefer Public sector banks 'as far as possible'
I had a very very bitter experience with a major private sector bank even when they have a dedicated education loan arm. I had to apply to the public sector bank after waiting for one month. In a nut shell I found the public sector bank much more professional and organized. They processed my loan in five working days. So avoid private bank as much as possible.
Margin Calculation
I was totally bowled over on this point. On bank's website you will see margin written as 15%-20% but that does not tell the complete story. That is the minimum margin that you will have to put in but there is no limit for the maximum. What does this mean? Let us see some examples (I am assuming public sector bank):
Example 1: You are going for Indian education. In this case maximum loan limit will be 7.5 lakh. So if margin is written as 15% on the website it will be 15% till the total fees is 7.5/0.85 = 8.8 lakh.
As the fees goes up, 7.5 lakh remains 7.5 lakh but your margin goes up. So if the total fees is 15 lakh. Your margin will be 50%. So you have to give 7.5 lakh to the bank and they put their 7.5 lakh and give 15 lakh to the college.
And if your fees is 6 lakh, you will get loan for just 6*0.85= 5.1 lakh
In case of Indian education this margin thing does not make much difference as such unless your total fees is less than 7.5 lakh and you want loan to fund it.
Example 2:
A. You want to go abroad and total fees is 50 lakh.
B. Maximum loan available for foreign education is 20 lakh (with collateral and cosigner).
C. Margin on website is 15%
D. You are arranging 'some' funds from abroad may be a collateral and cosigner free loan from a foreign bank. Let us assume 20 lakh. So you need 30 lakh from Indian bank but max available is 20 lakh
Now here the problem is that even when you are not using same collateral for the foreign loan and also the cosigner is exclusive to the Indian loan, the bank will tell you an unwritten policy that you cannot take the other loan for the same program. But you want to take it as the interest rates are very low in developed countries.
If you don't show that loan here is the calculation:
Total Fees: 50 lakh
Loan by Indian bank: 20 lakh
Your funds: 30 lakh (at least that's what you tell the bank as you don't want to bring other loan in picture. And also don't forget that you will need your funds for living and other expenses)
You can at least convince them that you have some relative in that city who will take care of you living so you need loan just for tuition. This will help in margin calculation.
So here is the calculation:
Bank assumes that you want tuition fees loan for 20/50 = 40% amount and 60% you will pay. So your contribution margin becomes 60% (not 15% as written on the website). Meaning every time you want to make a payment to the college you need to deposit 60% amount with the bank and they will add 40% and then will transfer 100% to the college. And this transaction has to happen through them only. So how do you use foreign loan? Well you can't and second you don't have 30 lakh (generally!) as you will need your funds for living expenses.
So be careful before paying any money to the bank for loan processing. Get these things clarified. Thankfully the above mentioned private bank was not bothered about the foreign loan.
Women Power!
I came to know that public sector banks have policy to give 1% discount in interest rate to female students. Although no use to me but may be to you if you are a girl!
Mode of interest payment
If you pay interest along with your education you get 1% discount in interest rate in public sector bank. Unfortunately the private bank did not give me the option to pay it later. But this condition varies depending upon program's reputation and might be negotiable in some cases with private banks. So check for that.
Interest Rate comparison
Try to arrange as much funds from the foreign country as interest rates are very low in most of the countries which are possible MBA destinations. In India private bank will offer a little less rate.
The shocker!
A friend of mine got the loan from the same private bank for the same amount without any cosigner and collateral! I had to handle the 6 weeks' craziness for the same loan even when I was providing collateral of more than double value, a cosigner, an additional cosigner and one guarantor! So I believe things are pretty random!
{added later..}
Early loan payment policy
This is also one crucial point to consider. As the interest rate of Indian loan will be high, you would like to payback it as early as possible. However sometimes banks charge fine for this early payment of loan. Based on my experience I found that public sector banks don't have such rule but private ones do.
{added later..}
Processing charges
The public sector bank which which I dealt had a policy under which they would charge 1% of the total amount as processing charges. However if you actually use that loan they would adjust that amount. While the private bank will charge straight 1% and no adjustment later. So if your loan amount is 20 lakh, you will pay additional 20k to the private bank.
Final words of wisdom.. it helps (A Lot) to have some networking with the bank manager where you are applying for loan!
Showing posts with label Banking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Banking. Show all posts
July 5, 2011
September 11, 2010
ISB: Banking and Capital markets conclave
Today I attended ISB's 5th annual Capital Markets Conclave, which for the first time incorporated banking and became 'Banking and Capital Markets Conclave'. It was a full day event with a key note speech and a panel discussion on each of Banking and Capital Markets tracks. It was a nice experience to listen to some of the big people in the banking and capital markets in India.
The key note speech on Banking was given by Mrs. Vedika Bhandarkar, the Managing Director and Vice Chairman, Credit Suisse,India. She carries more than 20 years of experience in the banking industry. She talked about banking as global phenomenon in pre and post financial crisis world. She highlighted that the banks of the emerging world have become bigger than they were before the crisis and that the case is opposite in the developed world. She also mentioned four main focus and opportunity areas for Indian banking industry: Rural sector, Tapping good talent, Infrastructure and Technology adoption. One other thing that she highlighted is that as Indian corporates are going global, they would expect the Indian banks to support them in the foreign territory and that this is a huge opportunity for the Indian banking industry.
The keynote was followed by a panel discussion on Indian banking industry, reforms, challenges and opportunity. The panelists were from the institutions such as Kotak Bank, SocGen, Muthoot Finance, HDFC Bank etc. They discussed about RBI policy and its effectiveness, the global crisis was termed as North Atlantic crisis!, Indian banks going global, Micro-finance, Infrastructure and need for corporate bond market.
--Delicious Lunch--
Following the lunch it was time for Capital Markets. The keynote was given by Mr. Sanjay Nayyar, the India CEO of KKR. He talked about how Indian markets have emerged over the past two decades and where are they heading to. He also talked about what are the high level challenges in Indian Private equity markets and what we, as a country, need to do to see a better future of the markets.
The keynote was followed by another panel discussion on Capital Markets. Among the panelists there was a popular name Mr. Ramesh Damani. Others were people from Morgan Stanley, a corporate law firm, an M&A expert, a bond market expert, the chairman of MCX-SX etc. I liked the opening remarks of each of the panelists as they talked very authoritatively about their own domain and expertise. Some of the remarks were really informative. However, the one thing that I did not like about this panel is that, in the open discussion everyone was talking about only one thing: Corporate bond markets are not developed in India. Though I agree with the concern but what about the one which does exist: The Equity capital market and we all know about it to a large extent. Apart from this last piece, I liked the conclave very much.
Looking forward to the ISB's 'Services in Emerging Markets' Conference on 23rd and 24th of this month.
The key note speech on Banking was given by Mrs. Vedika Bhandarkar, the Managing Director and Vice Chairman, Credit Suisse,India. She carries more than 20 years of experience in the banking industry. She talked about banking as global phenomenon in pre and post financial crisis world. She highlighted that the banks of the emerging world have become bigger than they were before the crisis and that the case is opposite in the developed world. She also mentioned four main focus and opportunity areas for Indian banking industry: Rural sector, Tapping good talent, Infrastructure and Technology adoption. One other thing that she highlighted is that as Indian corporates are going global, they would expect the Indian banks to support them in the foreign territory and that this is a huge opportunity for the Indian banking industry.
The keynote was followed by a panel discussion on Indian banking industry, reforms, challenges and opportunity. The panelists were from the institutions such as Kotak Bank, SocGen, Muthoot Finance, HDFC Bank etc. They discussed about RBI policy and its effectiveness, the global crisis was termed as North Atlantic crisis!, Indian banks going global, Micro-finance, Infrastructure and need for corporate bond market.
--Delicious Lunch--
Following the lunch it was time for Capital Markets. The keynote was given by Mr. Sanjay Nayyar, the India CEO of KKR. He talked about how Indian markets have emerged over the past two decades and where are they heading to. He also talked about what are the high level challenges in Indian Private equity markets and what we, as a country, need to do to see a better future of the markets.
The keynote was followed by another panel discussion on Capital Markets. Among the panelists there was a popular name Mr. Ramesh Damani. Others were people from Morgan Stanley, a corporate law firm, an M&A expert, a bond market expert, the chairman of MCX-SX etc. I liked the opening remarks of each of the panelists as they talked very authoritatively about their own domain and expertise. Some of the remarks were really informative. However, the one thing that I did not like about this panel is that, in the open discussion everyone was talking about only one thing: Corporate bond markets are not developed in India. Though I agree with the concern but what about the one which does exist: The Equity capital market and we all know about it to a large extent. Apart from this last piece, I liked the conclave very much.
Looking forward to the ISB's 'Services in Emerging Markets' Conference on 23rd and 24th of this month.
Labels:
Banking,
career,
Financial Services,
Indian Economy,
Indian Stock Market,
ISB,
mba
September 27, 2008
India's Global Bank
When we compare India's size in terms of economy, which was near about one trillion dollars last year, it stands nowhere in front of the US, Japan or China. In terms of the size of companies in the key sectors such as oil, mining, shipping and many others also, India still is very far behind. But when we talk about the Banking and Finance sector, this gap becomes huge. There is hardly any institution in India which can make itself visible in this industry on the world stage. Be it any form of banking and finance business such as retail, corporate, investment, insurance or loans we cannot think of any player with ‘Made in India’ tag in the world market.
Historically private players were suppressed by the government in this field with a lot of regulations and they could not expand themselves much. Public sectors banks which used to enjoy government's supremacy were inefficient in working and there was hardly any vision in terms of business growth. This resulted in low penetration of banking services in the rural India and hence low level of awareness among the people. People in remote areas still depend on private money lenders to a large extant. Services such as insurance are in even worse situation.
In terms of corporate banking also there is nothing much to boast about. Though there are public and private financial institutions which provide funds to the corporate houses for their needs but when it comes to big ticket buyouts or global M&A, Indian firms always have to look at global players for help. Not just meeting the requirement of funds but also for consulting, advice and arbitration also these global players comes into the picture always. As we have seen the appetite of Indian companies rising for global M&A, India is losing millions and millions of dollars in consulting fees only.
Because of the lack of scale, Indian financial companies are unable to take advantage of sudden opportunities that come into the markets from time to time, latest US financial crisis being one of the examples, where many global brands are up for sale at rock bottom prices. Many European, Chinese and Japanese institutions are in the fray to buy American companies but India is nowhere in the picture. I believe it is very necessary to create global scale financial super power houses based out of India if we dream to become developed nation and play a much more significant role on the world stage.
Historically private players were suppressed by the government in this field with a lot of regulations and they could not expand themselves much. Public sectors banks which used to enjoy government's supremacy were inefficient in working and there was hardly any vision in terms of business growth. This resulted in low penetration of banking services in the rural India and hence low level of awareness among the people. People in remote areas still depend on private money lenders to a large extant. Services such as insurance are in even worse situation.
In terms of corporate banking also there is nothing much to boast about. Though there are public and private financial institutions which provide funds to the corporate houses for their needs but when it comes to big ticket buyouts or global M&A, Indian firms always have to look at global players for help. Not just meeting the requirement of funds but also for consulting, advice and arbitration also these global players comes into the picture always. As we have seen the appetite of Indian companies rising for global M&A, India is losing millions and millions of dollars in consulting fees only.
Because of the lack of scale, Indian financial companies are unable to take advantage of sudden opportunities that come into the markets from time to time, latest US financial crisis being one of the examples, where many global brands are up for sale at rock bottom prices. Many European, Chinese and Japanese institutions are in the fray to buy American companies but India is nowhere in the picture. I believe it is very necessary to create global scale financial super power houses based out of India if we dream to become developed nation and play a much more significant role on the world stage.
Labels:
Banking,
Economics,
Financial Services,
Indian Economy
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)