Showing posts with label recession. Show all posts
Showing posts with label recession. Show all posts

September 21, 2010

Recession is for Individuals not for big corporates

Just saw a talk by Russel Napier, Strategist - CLSA on CNBC, given to an audience of Indian Association of Investment Professionals (IAIP). In the talk his main point was that American equities are available at good valuation and people should buy it. To substantiate his argument he presented a lot of data of US stock markets captured in past 140 years. He also highlighted a couple of very interesting points which to some extent are applicable to other markets as well.

First point that he mentioned was that valuing equities based on dividend yield does not hold good anymore. The reasoning is that in the recent past a lot of large corporations have returned money to shareholders not just in the form of dividends but also in the form of share buybacks. Hence this also has to be accounted while doing the calculations.

He said that being the symbol of capitalism, the US economy has seen almost everything that can be expected from a free economy. It has seen high growth periods, recessions, political turmoil, a lot of innovation among other things. His point was that even being such a great economy, the US markets also could not sustain P/E more than 20 for long in the history and every time came down to more sustainable levels. So according to me the take away from this point is that even though Indian economy might be like an Oasis in the midst of financial uncertainty, there is every good or bad reason that the markets will come to their logical levels after seeing such a dramatic rise in past some weeks.

One other very important and catchy point that he mentioned is that the recession is for individuals not for big corporates. It is individuals who lost the jobs, who defaulted on their loans, who saw pay cuts and live fearing due to uncertainty. For big corporates, he mentioned that the recession was short lived and got over long back. Markets value has increased significantly since the bottom of market, bankruptcies were bailed out, earnings are almost back on track, there are more than $400 billion lying in cash with the corporates and many such data points. So in the end it is the individual who is affected because there is 10% unemployment in the US or may be because lesser people are doing more work.

He argued that the model of the society is not sustainable in which individuals are scarified to save the corporates or in which the corporates dictate the policy.